Target Operating Model vs Business Process Outsourcing: Which Improves Operational Efficiency?
Business process outsourcing usually enters the conversation when an operations leader is buried. Order entry runs a week behind, invoices go out late, and the people who know the process are working weekends to keep up. A vendor offers to take the whole function off their plate at a lower cost per transaction, and the offer looks hard to refuse.
Around the same time, someone else suggests stepping back to redesign how the business runs before moving any work. That’s the target operating model route, and it sounds slower. So the question becomes which path makes operations more efficient. The better path depends on two things. The first is what the current process costs you today. The second is whether the process is worth keeping in its current shape at all.
Two Answers to Two Different Questions
A target operating model and business process outsourcing get compared often, yet they answer different questions.
Deloitte describes an operating model as how value is created by an organization, and by whom. The target version is the one you’re aiming for. It lays out the capabilities the business needs, which part of the organization owns each one, and how decisions get made. Deloitte also notes that each capability can be developed, acquired, partnered, or outsourced.
Business process outsourcing answers a narrower question. IBM defines it as hiring external service providers to handle noncore business functions or processes. Typical examples include accounting, payroll, customer support, and data entry.
Seen side by side, outsourcing is one of the sourcing choices a target operating model makes. The model decides what the business should do and who should do it. Outsourcing is one way to fill a specific role in that design. Trouble starts when a company outsources first and designs later. The vendor then inherits whatever shape the process was in on the day the contract was signed.
What Business Process Outsourcing Does Well
Outsourcing earns its place for good reasons. A specialist provider runs the same process for many clients, so it has trained staff, tested tools, and coverage across time zones. For work that’s repetitive, well documented, and easy to measure, that specialization can lower cost and raise consistency.
The reasons companies outsource have also shifted. Deloitte’s 2024 Global Outsourcing Survey of more than 500 executives found that skilled talent and agility now rank alongside cost reduction as key drivers. The same survey found that 83% of executives are using AI as part of their outsourced services. In other words, many providers now sell automation along with labor.
Business process outsourcing also gives internal staff time for work that sets the company apart. When a finance lead stops keying invoices, they can spend that time on cash flow and pricing instead. For many growing companies, that trade alone justifies the contract.
Where Outsourcing Loses Efficiency
The savings on a business process outsourcing contract are easy to measure. The costs tend to show up somewhere else.
The first cost is the handoff itself. Every outsourced process has a boundary where work passes between your people and the provider’s people. Orders cross that boundary, questions come back, and exceptions wait in someone’s inbox. Each crossing adds delay, and the delays rarely show up on the vendor’s report, since the vendor measures its own part of the process.
The second cost is data. Providers often work in their own ticketing or workflow tools, then copy results back into your customer relationship management (CRM) or enterprise resource planning (ERP) system. When the copy lags or misses a field, your reports drift away from what happened. Over time, the gaps between systems become the place where revenue quietly leaks, because nobody owns them.
The third cost is the process you handed over. If the work was messy before the contract, the provider now runs the mess at a lower hourly rate. IBM also lists hidden costs among the risks of outsourcing, such as currency swings, upgrades, and delays. It adds the difficulty of replacing a vendor you rely on heavily.
Outsourcing can still be the right call, as long as you know what you’re handing over and how the work comes back.
What a Target Operating Model Settles First
A target operating model starts from the other end. Before anyone signs a contract, it asks which capabilities the business needs and how well each one runs today.
That review usually covers four things. It names the capabilities, such as quoting, order fulfillment, billing, and customer support. It assigns an owner to each one and places it inside the organization. It sets the rules for how decisions move between groups. Finally, it chooses the systems that hold each piece of data.
Sourcing decisions come after that work, and they get easier. Once a process has a clear owner, a documented flow, and a system of record, it’s much simpler to judge whether an outside provider could run it well. It’s also easier to write a contract that measures the right outcome.
The catch is that operating model work fails when it ignores the systems a company already runs. A design that looks clean on a slide still has to fit the CRM and ERP your people use every day. That’s why a good model starts from a map of the current state and shapes the design to fit your systems.
Target Operating Model vs Business Process Outsourcing at a Glance
| Target operating model | Business process outsourcing | |
|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | How the business should run and who does what | Who should run one specific process |
| Where efficiency comes from | Removing duplicate work and unclear handoffs | Lower cost per task and specialist staff |
| What changes | Roles, decisions, systems, and data ownership | Who performs the work, usually not how |
| Main risk | Designs that ignore existing systems | Outsourcing a broken process as-is |
| Best fit | Growing companies with tangled processes | Stable, well-documented, measurable work |
Deciding Which Work to Keep and Which to Hand Off
With a target operating model in place, each process can be sorted on its own merits. A few patterns tend to hold across companies.
Work That Usually Outsources Well
Processes that are stable, rule-based, and easy to measure are the strongest candidates. Payroll processing, accounts payable data entry, and first-line support often fit. The provider can follow a documented procedure, and you can check the output against a clear standard each month.
Work That Usually Stays In-House
Processes that carry the company’s judgment usually stay inside. Pricing approvals, lead routing, and decisions about which customers get priority all fall into this group. These rules change as the business changes, and the people setting them need to see the results quickly. Keeping those rules in one governed place makes them easier to adjust, whoever ends up doing the day-to-day work.
Work That Sits in Between
Some processes split down the middle. A provider might handle the volume while your people own the exceptions. In that case, write down exactly where the line falls and which system holds the record at each step. Otherwise, exceptions bounce between the two sides with nobody accountable for them.
Automate the Handoff Before You Hand Off the Work
A lot of work that ends up outsourced is copying. Someone moves an order from the CRM into the ERP, updates a project board when a deal closes, or retypes a payment into a spreadsheet. Outsourcing that work moves the copying to a cheaper desk, yet the copying still happens.
Before signing a contract, it’s worth checking how much of the process is really people carrying data between systems. Small automations can often take those steps out entirely, and the remaining work becomes easier to keep in-house or to hand to a provider. These data flow examples show what that looks like for orders, payments, and project kickoffs.
The order matters here. If you automate first, the provider takes on a shorter, cleaner process, and the contract can focus on work that still needs a person. If you outsource first, the provider may build its own workarounds for the copying, and those workarounds become one more thing to untangle later.
Keeping Data Whole When Work Moves Outside
When an outside provider takes over a process, it needs access to your data, and your systems need its results. That two-way traffic is where many outsourcing arrangements lose accuracy.
Start by naming the system of record for every piece of data the provider touches. Then decide whether the provider works directly in that system or sends results back through a defined feed. Either approach can work, as long as everyone agrees which record is the real one. Companies whose systems all read from a single source of truth have an easier time later. They can bring in a provider, swap one out, or pull work back in-house without rebuilding their data.
Measuring Efficiency on Both Paths
Efficiency claims are easy to make and hard to compare, so it helps to agree on the measures before choosing a path. Four of them tend to show the real picture.
First, measure cycle time from start to finish, such as the days from a signed order to a shipped one. A provider’s report usually covers only its own slice of that timeline, so the handoffs on either side stay invisible unless you track the whole span.
Second, track rework. Count how often a record comes back for correction, whether the mistake started inside the company or with the provider. Rework is where outsourced savings tend to disappear.
Third, look at cost per finished outcome, including the internal time spent managing the vendor. An invoice processed for less money still costs more if someone on your side checks every one of them.
Finally, check data accuracy in the system of record. If the numbers in your CRM or ERP drift from what happened, the efficiency gain is partly an illusion, because decisions start running on bad information.
When Business Process Outsourcing Makes Sense First
Sometimes the order has to flip. A sudden spike in volume, a key person leaving, or a specialized task like payroll tax filing can make outsourcing the fastest relief available.
In those cases, bring in the provider, but treat the contract as a bridge. Keep the scope narrow, document the process as the provider learns it, and write down how the work would come back if needed. That way, the operating model work can still happen afterward, and the outsourced process becomes one more input to it instead of a fixed point nobody can change.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Business Process Outsourcing Part of a Target Operating Model?
Often it is. The model decides which capabilities the business needs and how each one is sourced. Outsourcing is one of those sourcing options, alongside building the capability in-house or partnering for it.
What Is the Difference Between Outsourcing and a Shared Services Center?
A shared services center keeps the work inside the company but pulls it into one group that serves several departments or regions. Outsourcing moves the work to an outside provider. Deloitte’s 2024 survey found that in-house centers are gaining momentum again, even as investment in outsourcing keeps growing.
Can a Smaller Company Use a Target Operating Model?
Smaller companies can use one, and the work is usually lighter. A company with a few dozen people can map its main processes, owners, and systems on a single page. A System Automation Engagement (SAE) Map charts every system and handoff that way, which gives the sourcing conversation a clear starting point.
Should an Outsourcing Contract Pay for Activity or Outcomes?
Outcomes are usually easier to defend, because they tie the provider’s pay to what the business needs. Deloitte’s 2024 survey found that outcome-based models have grown in adoption. Still, outcomes only work when both sides agree on how to measure them, which brings the conversation back to clear owners and a trusted system of record.
Find the Work Worth Keeping
Some of your processes belong with a specialist, and some carry the judgment that makes your company different. Fruition RevOps can help you see which is which before anything moves. There’s no obligation attached.